साहित्य चिंतनSahitya Chintan

Note · · 3 min read

Hindi vs Urdu: one spoken language, two literatures

How Hindi and Urdu differ: shared grammar and everyday speech, different scripts and literary vocabulary, and what it means for reading Premchand or Ghalib.

Short answer

Hindi and Urdu share their grammar and most everyday words, so speakers understand each other easily, but Hindi is written in Devanagari and draws its formal vocabulary from Sanskrit, while Urdu is written in a Perso-Arabic script and draws its formal vocabulary from Persian and Arabic.

Key takeaways

  • Everyday spoken Hindi and Urdu are largely mutually intelligible; linguists often call the shared base Hindustani.
  • The scripts differ completely: Devanagari runs left to right, Urdu's Nastaliq style of Perso-Arabic script runs right to left.
  • Formal and literary registers diverge: Sanskrit-derived words in Hindi, Persian and Arabic words in Urdu.
  • Writers such as Premchand worked in both, so many classics exist in Hindi and Urdu versions.
  • If you read Devanagari, transliterated Urdu poetry is a practical bridge to writers like Ghalib.

Ask two people from Delhi and Lahore to chat about cricket and they will understand each other without effort. Hand one of them a newspaper from the other's city and neither can read a word. That gap, between a shared spoken language and two separate written traditions, is the simplest way to understand Hindi and Urdu.

Are Hindi and Urdu the same language?

In everyday speech they are close to one language, often called Hindustani, but they have separate scripts, formal vocabularies and literary traditions.

The grammar is the same. Verbs, pronouns, postpositions and sentence order match. So does most of the vocabulary you need to buy vegetables, give directions or argue about a film. Linguists often treat them as two standard forms of one language. Politics, religion and history have pushed them apart as written languages since the 19th century, which is why they are usually counted as two.

How are the scripts different?

Hindi uses Devanagari, written left to right, while Urdu uses the Nastaliq style of the Perso-Arabic script, written right to left.

Devanagari is an abugida: each consonant carries an inherent vowel, and other vowels are marked with signs around it. It is also used for Sanskrit, Marathi and Nepali. Urdu's script comes from Persian, which took it from Arabic and added letters for sounds Arabic lacks. Nastaliq, the flowing, slanted style used for Urdu, is beautiful and hard for beginners, because letters change shape depending on their position.

So a reader of one cannot read the other without learning a new script. That is the single biggest practical difference.

Where does the vocabulary split?

Everyday words overlap, but formal and literary words come from Sanskrit in Hindi and from Persian and Arabic in Urdu.

Meaning Common to both Formal Hindi Formal Urdu
book kitab pustak kitab
thank you shukriya / dhanyavad dhanyavad shukriya
school school vidyalaya madrasa
love pyar prem ishq, mohabbat
world duniya sansar duniya

The higher the register, the further apart they move. A Hindi news bulletin uses many Sanskrit-derived words a Lucknow Urdu speaker might find stiff. An Urdu ghazal uses Persian words a Hindi speaker from a Sanskrit-heavy school may need a glossary for. In between, the everyday language stays shared.

What does this mean for reading literature?

Many writers before 1947 wrote in both, so a reader who knows one script can often find the work in that script.

Premchand is the clearest case. He began writing in Urdu under the name Nawab Rai and moved increasingly to Hindi from the mid-1910s. Many of his stories exist in both versions, sometimes revised by him. A Hindi reader can read him in Devanagari, and an Urdu reader can read many of the same stories in Urdu. Our guide to Premchand lists where to start.

Urdu poetry is the other big bridge. Ghalib, Mir, Faiz and others are loved by Hindi readers, who usually meet them in Devanagari transliteration. Rekhta, a free site run by a non-profit foundation, shows many poems in Urdu script, Devanagari and Roman letters side by side, with word meanings.

Which should you learn to read first?

Learn the script of the literature you most want to read, and use transliterations to explore the other.

If your goal is Premchand, Hindi short stories and the Hindi novel, start with Devanagari. If it is the ghazal, Urdu fiction such as Manto or Ismat Chughtai, or Pakistani writing, learn the Urdu script. Many heritage learners who already speak the shared language pick the script their family used. Our note on reading Devanagari slowly has practical habits for that first stage.

How official is each language?

Hindi in Devanagari is the official language of the Indian Union, Urdu is one of India's scheduled languages, and Urdu is the national language of Pakistan.

Article 343 of the Indian Constitution makes Hindi in Devanagari the official language of the Union, with English continuing alongside it. Urdu is listed in the Constitution's Eighth Schedule and is an official language in several Indian states and territories. In Pakistan, Urdu is the national language. These labels matter for schools and government, less for readers, who move between both literatures all the time.

A small experiment

Take a Premchand story you know and look for it in both Hindi and Urdu; Idgah is a good candidate, since it is widely reprinted in both. Read a paragraph of each with a transliteration. You will see the same sentences, almost the same words, and two different worlds of letters around them. Then try a Kabir doha and a Ghalib couplet side by side; the reading list has Kabir if you want a starting point.

Questions readers ask

Can a Hindi speaker understand Urdu?

In everyday conversation, mostly yes. Formal speech, news and especially poetry are harder, because the vocabulary moves toward Persian and Arabic. Reading is a different matter: without learning the script, a Hindi reader cannot read Urdu text.

Are Hindi films in Hindi or Urdu?

Mostly in the shared everyday language, with many Urdu words in dialogue and song lyrics. Film certificates usually say Hindi, but the language on screen is often closer to Hindustani.

Is Urdu an official language in India?

Urdu is one of the languages listed in the Eighth Schedule of the Indian Constitution and is an official language in some states and union territories. Hindi in Devanagari is the official language of the Union under Article 343.

Should I learn the Urdu script to read Urdu literature?

If you want to read Urdu poetry seriously, yes, eventually. To start, sites such as Rekhta show many poems in Devanagari and Roman transliteration alongside the Urdu script.

Sources